Business Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Sunday, Jan 23, 2011
ePaper | Mobile/PDA Version | Audio | Blogs

Investment World
Foreign Exchange

Group Sites

Investment World - Investments
Markets - Stock Markets
Columns - Micromotives
Market timing versus asset allocation

B. Venkatesh

Last week, we discussed how diversified and concentrated portfolio structures are both capable of generating alpha. We also explained why market timing is risky because such strategies make large bets on fewer stocks. Several readers responded, stating that market timing was a rewarding asset allocation strategy to generate alpha. This argument raises two questions. One, is market timing same as asset allocation? And two, is it worthwhile pursuing such strategies?

This article explains how market timing is different from asset allocation. It then shows why market timing, though attractive, is risky. It reiterates last week's discussion — market timing should be pursued by those confident about their strategies and disciplined enough to use risk management to control losses.

Market timing vs asset allocation

Market timing and tactical asset allocation involve moving in and out of an asset class. There is, however, a difference.

Market timing refers to the process wherein the investor shifts between a risky asset such as equity and cash equivalents such as money market funds.

Consider an active trader or a professional money manager who engages in trend-following strategies using technical analysis or quantitative modelling. This trader or money manager would obviously move into equity when she expects the market to do well and move out of equity when she expects prices to decline. Importantly, when this trader is underweight on equity, she is overweight on cash equivalents, otherwise called tactical cash.

Tactical asset allocation, in contrast, refers to the process of shifting between risky assets — equity and bonds. An investor would overweight equity when she believes it would perform well and overweight bonds otherwise. An investor or a professional money manager will engage in tactical asset allocation within the broad framework of strategic asset allocation.

Suppose an investor decides to have a 60-40 equity-bond allocation with a tactical range of 10 per cent for her retirement portfolio. The investor then has a leeway to carry equity exposure between 50 and 70 per cent.

Why is this distinction between market timing and tactical asset allocation important?

Asymmetric returns

Bonds provide higher returns than money market instruments. This means that market timing carries higher levels of underperformance risk compared with tactical asset allocation.

The flip side is that market timing also carries potential for higher reward because of its larger exposure to equity. The question is: Should investors engage in market timing?

Empirical study conducted in this area argues that market timing is risky. There are two reasons to support this argument. One, if the investor or the professional money manager misses the days when the market finishes markedly higher, which happens for about 20 per cent of the total trading days in a year, the portfolio is likely to underperform its benchmark. And two, if the investor or the money manager is invested on the worst days, the chances of the portfolio recovering losses becomes difficult. This is because of the problem of negative returns-compounding.

Suppose a portfolio is currently worth Rs 15,000, gaining 50 per cent in one year on an initial investment of Rs 10,000.

This portfolio has to give up only a third (33 per cent) of its value to end-up with the initial investment of Rs 10,000.

If the portfolio instead declines 50 per cent in one year to Rs 5,000, it would then require 100 per cent gain to end-up with the initial investment of Rs 10,000! The loss-recovery process is, thus, steeper. And this makes market timing risky.


Market timing is nevertheless rewarding, which drives investors to engage in such strategies. It is, however, important to consider associated risks.

No amount of technical analysis or quantitative modelling is likely to help investors avoid losses due to noise trading. Strict risk management rules are necessary to control losses; for it is the management of losses that differentiates a successful market timer from the rest.

(The author is the founder of Navera Consulting, a firm that offers wealth-mapping and investor-learning solutions. He can be reached at

Related Stories:
Why protection assets are crucial for short-term traders
Multi-asset class portfolio: Leaning on asset allocation for optimal returns

More Stories on : Investments | Stock Markets | Micromotives

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
Market timing versus asset allocation

Savings tips for young earners
IDFC Infrastructure Bonds — For additional tax savings
ESOPs turn out to be money-spinners
Indians as money managers
Inflation lays siege to margins
Fund update
Fund Talk
SBI Magnum FMCG Fund: Hold
MOSt Shares M100 ETF — One-stop shop for mid-caps
UTI Unit Linked Insurance Plan: Invest
Distilling the concept of under-recoveries
Provogue India: Buy
V-Guard Industries: Book profits
Container Corporation of India: Book profits
Bajaj Auto: Buy
Axis Bank: Buy
Query Corner — Nagarjuna Construction at key support
Sizzling stocks: LIC Housing Finance (Rs 194.2)
Coffee outlook
Pivotals: Reliance Industries (Rs 986.5)
Index Outlook: Poised at significant support
Consider going long on Punj Lloyd
Drywalls can chop wood usage
Hyderabad realty in consolidation phase
Building on alternative materials
Chennai to host BAI convention
Baskets of X
Bull's Eye
Heard in the studio
Prominent bulk deals on NSE and BSE
Why one's credit record matters
Relief for Lavasa stakeholders, for now
‘Slump in markets, right time for ESOPs'
Why we like risky bets
Only the really, really paranoid may survive

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | The Hindu ePaper | Business Line | Business Line ePaper | Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2011, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line