Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Sunday, Apr 21, 2002

Investment World
Features
Stocks
Port Info
Archives

Group Sites

Investment World - ISPs
Info-Tech - ISPs


Telephony: Netting a better deal

Krishnan Thiagarajan

CONSUMER is king. For Indians, this worn out cliche has remained a derisive phrase and invariably generated much sarcasm. But for once, the telecom industry is poised to load the dice in favour of the consumer. Through a plethora of bold initiatives by the Government (in association with the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India, the apex regulator for the telecom industry), several goodies are coming the way of the consumer. Some of these are:

  • The introduction of the fourth cellular operator and the dynamic competition among the cellular players have driven down the cellular tariffs to a little over Rs 2 per minute on an average, and over Rs 4 at peak tariffs.

  • The highly publicised battle between BSNL (Bharat Sanchar Nigam — the incumbent long distance operator) and Bharti Telesonic over national long distance tariffs (or STD rates) led to BSNL dropping tariffs over 50 per cent for STD calls made using both basic and cellular services. But these rates are likely to move downwards as more national long distance players, such as Reliance and Tatas, enter the fray.

  • In a path-breaking move, the Government announced an early termination of Videsh Sanchar Nigam's monopoly over international long distance telephony (or ISD) to March 31, 2002 and opened up ISD to private sector competition from April 1, 2002. Going by the initial overtures from private operators, the ISD tariffs are also poised to move downwards in the months to come. After resisting the moves by private operators to legalise Internet telephony for years, the Government finally legalised it with effect from April 1, 2002.

    Instead of focussing on these services whose effects are already visible to the consumer, Business Line attempts to focus on two new services — Internet telephony which became legal in India from April 1, and limited mobility services using the Wireless-in-Local Loop platform given the final go-ahead by the Apellate Tribunal in mid-March this years. These two services are poised to significantly alter the scope and usage of telephony across the country:

    Internet telephony

    There are three different types of Internet telephony services that can be offered to consumers, according to the government guidelines. Before launching into the different forms of Internet telephony, some pre-requisites need to be borne in mind (look at Table).

    The three types of service are:

    PC-to-PC

    This is the most fundamental type of service. In this case, a consumer can make a phone call from a PC connected to the Internet in India, to another Internet-connected PC, say, in India or the US.

    Obviously, both the PCs must be connected to the same or compatible software and must be switched on at the same time to be able to use this service. As long as consumers download the same software at both ends, this service is automatically available to anyone with an Internet connection. Except for the Internet service provider charges, there is no other cost. Hence, this service is suited more for the home environment than to cybercafes.

    PC-to-telephone

  • The mechanics: Using this service, a consumer in India using the PC (with downloaded software for this purpose) sends a request to a server (in the US) with the telephone number to be dialled in the US. That server (proxy or otherwise), in turn, dials the local US number and establishes connectivity.

    Actually, this is the kind of service sought to be widely exploited by ISPs in India. Sify and Data Access are among the early to offer this service. Quite a few national and regional ISPs are likely to follow suit soon. As the current regulations provide that this service can be offered only by Indian ISPs, these players are in the course of entering into tie-ups with foreign service providers, such as Dialpad, Net2Phone, Phonefree, to offer similar services to consumers in India, based on revenue sharing arrangements. These foreign players have already been offering competing services to Indian consumers that require payment in dollars using a credit card.

    In stark contrast, the Indian ISPs are positioning themselves to provide the same offerings in rupees (though at a higher cost vis-à-vis players, such as dialpad or Net2Phone) along with, probably, higher levels of accountability to Indian consumers. The current Internet telephony regulations state that only calls directed abroad can be made from a PC in India. Calls within the country are banned to protect the revenue streams of the national long distance, or the STD, players.

  • Business models: Different business models are emerging to exploit this service, planning to offer pre-paid and post-paid calling cards (just like the pre-paid ISP packs) for fixed sums of money that can be used at both cybercafes and homes for PC-to-telephone calls. Using the pin number available in the cards, consumers can make the PC-to-phone call.

    Another model the ISPs are considering is to use their Web sites as portals, just like the present arrangement for Internet access. Sooner or latter, it is likely that Internet telephony will be bundled with dial-up Internet access packs and sold by ISPs through retail outlets.

  • Cost of access: Most ISPs admit that the cost of access will be in the Rs 7-8 range per minute in the initial stages; the rates will reduce, depending on the popularity of the service. Though this cost is significantly lower than the peak-hour ceiling rates of Rs 40.80 (for a call to the US) prescribed by TRAI, it is higher than the rates offered under different schemes by foreign service providers. The rates of foreign players, such as Net2Phone, dialpad or mediaring are pitched at Rs 3-4 per minute, and even as low as Rs 1-2 per minute in some calling plans. However, there is no guarantee of voice quality in any of these services.

    IP based terminals for Telephone-to-Telephone

    This is a highly sophisticated and expensive version of Internet telephony service that uses IP-enabled terminals on both the originating and terminating based on certain standards prescribed by telecommunication bodies, such as International Telecommunications Union.

    The current guidelines prescribe that these can be used for both domestic and international calls. However, as they involve installation of expensive equipment upfront, they are probably not directly relevant to consumers, except the high networth individuals.

    Send this article to Friends by E-Mail

  • Stories in this Section
    VMC Software: Accept


    VSNL: Reject
    Industrial machinery: Cranking up
    Restructuring to grow
    `Expansion market sustained us' — Mr Satish Tandon, Managing Director, Alfa Laval (India)
    Industrial machinery: These stocks still interest
    US-64: Avoid fresh exposures/Exit in May 2003
    Canexpo: Pare exposures
    Zurich India Capital Builder: Invest
    Pioneer ITI Pharma: Hold/Avoid fresh exposures
    Morgan Stanley -- Privatisation, the dominant theme
    Benchmarks for debt schemes
    Wipro: Cut exposures
    HDFC Bank: Sell/Buy on declines
    HLL: Hold/Avoid fresh exposures
    Kinetic Engineering: Book profits
    Morepen Laboratories: Hold/Avoid fresh exposures
    Infotech Enterprises: Cut exposures
    EPF earnings: Distributing it better
    Downside remains
    Trading volumes improve
    Nifty Apr 1140 call actively traded
    May contracts could dominate next week
    Market makers for single-stock futures
    Options help guide
    Futures guide
    NTPC: Power at a price
    Corporate governance: Character, the key
    `Short-term equity is zero sum game' — Mr K. N. Siva Subramanian, Fund Manager, Pioneer-ITI Mu
    Telephony: Netting a better deal
    Limited mobility services
    Political uncertainty dampens sentiment
    Open offer from parents pushes up Wartsila India
    Sustained weakness in HLL
    Book profit in Digital GlobalSoft
    Nasdaq: Upward momentum
    Loans, perquisites & investments
    Whither the great Indian common market?
    Effect of `Nifty' changes
    Grey areas in Takeover Code
    UTI's balance-sheet: Liabilities tip assets
    UTI: Ten numbers that tell a tale
    Bleaker and bleaker
    It adds up!


    The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
    Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | Home |

    Copyright © 2002, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line