Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Friday, Apr 21, 2006

Cross Currency

Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Consumerism
States - Tamil Nadu

HC asks Housing Board officials to act non-arbitrarily

Our Legal Correspondent

`Discretionary powers to officers do not absolve Board of duty'

Chennai , April 20

The Madras High Court has held that the Tamil Nadu Housing Board being a statutory body was required to act non-arbitrarily.

Conferment of discretion on its officers did not relieve the Board of duty to act fairly and in a non-arbitrary way since power exercised by officers flew from contract between Board and its customers.

The Court was hearing a writ appeal from an allottee of a house in Perumalpuram, Tirunelveli, challenging the board's demand to pay interest and penal interest over and above amounts he had to pay as per original agreement between him and the board.

A Division Bench held in order dated October 21, 2003 that statutory bodies, such as Housing Board, should act in a non-arbitrary manner and legally in fixing price for the plots and houses.

Extraordinary delay

Citing the case of the appellant, Mr K.V. Krishnan, the Bench observed that the allotment of the house in Tirunelveli was made on July 12, 1988. The amount of Rs 12,133, which the respondent (TNHB) sought to recover now, was an amount that even, according to the Board, should have been included in the cost as on that date, but had omitted to do so.

The amount, which it said should have been included, was the amount determined by it as interest on the sum of Rs 80,000 (which was the tentative cost of the house fixed on June 30, 1987) till July 12, 1988 (allotment date) plus penal interest on the same sum for the same period at 12 per cent. As to how penal interest could be levied for this period had not been explained, the Bench pointed out.

The Bench wondered that the Board chose to intimate the allottee about this additional amount only 13 years later, in 2001.

"There is no explanation forthcoming for this extraordinary long delay."

The Bench had directed the Board to execute the sale deed in favour of the appellant after collecting from him the sum of Rs 11,200 being interest at 14 per cent on Rs 80,000 from June 30, 1987 to July12, 1988 together with interest thereon at 8 per cent from June 1, 2001 till date of payment.

Disposing of a review petition from the respondent (TNHB), a Division Bench, comprising Mr Justice P. Sathasivam and Mr Justice J.A.K. Sampathkumar, held that the direction issued in the order dated October 21, 2003 of the Division Bench was to be confined to the parties to the said proceedings.

For other cases, interest had to be worked out/calculated as per terms and conditions agreed to between allottees and the Board.

In view of the fact that the appellant (Mr K.V. Krishnan) had paid interest as per the direction and the Board had also executed sale deed several years ago, the Bench said they were not inclined to disturb or alter the direction mentioned at this juncture. The said direction was confined to the said particular allottee.

More Stories on : Consumerism | Courts/Legal Issues | Real Estate & Construction | Tamil Nadu

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
Exclusive national weather portal launched

Canara Bank ups NRE deposit rates
Karnataka Bank NRE deposit rates
Big retailers double sourcing of garments from India
ICC corporate survey gets top rating for CM's positive efforts
Biscuit makers moot new duty structure to tackle price woes
Meet on public enterprises
Shipping cos to invest more in offshore sector
US cos seek speedy pharma reforms in India
CERC as Caesar's wife
`Implement GST without compromising fiscal autonomy'
`TN will lose out without VAT'
`Labour reforms vital for textile industry'
`Develop new industrial belt for textiles'
Philips bullish about `Vardaan'
DD to have live-feed of sports events
Andhra varsity, HSBC sign MoU
TDC, Australian varsity sign pact
US co develops device to monitor autonomic nervous system
CII to create 100 new billion-dollar cos
`Domestic violence is taken for granted in Bihar'
Variety in mid-day meals menu
`Reservation in pvt sector not conducive factor'
Insurers get ready for deregulation of tariffs
PM to inaugurate Hannover fair
Vesuvius hopes completion in May
Meet on public enterprises
`Go lean to be competitive'
HC asks Housing Board officials to act non-arbitrarily
Australian wheat set to arrive next week

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2006, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line