Business Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Wednesday, Dec 06, 2006
ePaper


News
Features
Stocks
Cross Currency
Shipping
Archives
Google

Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Courts/Legal Issues
Logistics - Taxation
States - Tamil Nadu
Tax laws can't be challenged for levy of different rates for different people: HC

Our Legal Correspondent

Chennai , Dec. 5

The Legislature is competent to classify persons or properties into different categories and tax them differently. The taxing statute cannot be challenged merely because different rates of taxation are prescribed for different categories of persons or objects, the Madras High Court has ruled.

The petitioner - Association of Managements of Nursery, Primary and Matriculation Schools - established by Catholic Church, contended that revision of tax from Rs 500 per quarter to Rs 150 per seat per quarter, was unconstitutional, discriminatory, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 21-A of the Constitution, besides being inconsistent with scheme of TN Motor Vehicles Taxation Act, 1974. Vehicles of educational institutions were in no way generating any income or profit. They were not involved in any trade or commerce.

On behalf of the State, it was submitted that levy was in the nature of compensatory tax. Expenditure incurred on maintenance and construction of roads and bridges was very much higher than total tax collected on motor vehicles. But educational institutions were charging heavy fees from students as transport charges. Poor and weaker sections used free bus passes issued by Government.

There was no violation of Articles 14 or 21-A of the Constitution.

The Bench noted that during 2005-06 total expenditure incurred for maintenance of roads and also for new ones amounted to Rs 2,202 crore whereas return from vehicle tax was only Rs 910 crore.

It was clear that tax imposed was part of regulatory measure and was to reimburse/recompensate service/facility provided.

Many schools and colleges, the Bench said, charged heavy fees towards transportation charges. It was not unreasonable to ask managements of such institutions to contribute towards cost of maintenance of roads, etc.

While dismissing petitions, the Bench said that the petitioners were at liberty to represent to the State for remission of tax since 2003 as they had not collected tax from students in view of the court's stay. Since students had passed out and gone, recovery of past dues would be difficult. If representations were made within four weeks, Government might consider the same sympathetically.

More Stories on : Courts/Legal Issues | Taxation | Tamil Nadu

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page



Stories in this Section
Investors move away from small savings


DaimlerChrysler biodiesel project enters final phase
TRAI proposes `carbon credits' for telcos
Biodiesel association seeks higher price
Coir Board considering health insurance plan
Tax laws can't be challenged for levy of different rates for different people: HC
Nod for Aspinwall group cos merger
Fed cut in sight
Fab policy: State's plea to PM
Indo-US `Totalisation Treaty' mooted
India confident of free trade pact with ASEAN by 2007
More trade, investment ties with Israel
US cos eye biz avenues here
Govt to promote risk taking, innovation in public sector
Sakhalin gas: ONGC may opt for direct marketing
Govt to approve formula for gas pricing: Deora
Thorium Power in tie-up talks with NTPC, NPCIL
Goa Carbon power generation foray
TN proposes mini-port at Cheyyur
With passing of Bill, TN moves into VAT system
National Geographic plans awards for factual films
CD Mart goes on stream
Banks cut back lending to realty, retail sectors
Panel to revise market property value guidelines in TN
Indian cos get more to buy property abroad
Construction sector urged to adopt modern technology
Gaining again
Knitwear workers' wage issue close to settlement
Report on women-media study
FDI in education: Demand may go up for NRI teachers
Rs 12 cr for North 24-Parganas
Call for Indian model of management
Non-destructive testing meet in Hyderabad
World Disabled Day observed
Ashwani Kumar to represent PM in Morocco
Over 1.5-lakh I-T returns taken up for scrutiny
50 l tonnes cotton export unlikely
Ban on pulses export can only be prospective: SC
Rice production hit by climate impact: Study
Vaidyaratnam Oushadhasala to branch out
Outbound travel roadshow in Jan
Kerala plans Rs 1,000-cr investment in tourism


The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | The Hindu ePaper | Business Line | Business Line ePaper | Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2006, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line