Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Wednesday, Mar 01, 2006


Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Taxation

If only consumers had lobbyists

S. Murlidharan

Pressure groups and lobbyists are available for business houses. But the poor consumer has none taking up cudgels for him.

The service tax rate is sought to be raised to 12.24 per cent from the existing 10.2 per cent. The service providers have nothing to lose from this and may even empathise with the Finance Minister when he says that this increase became necessary in achieving his ultimate objective of bringing about parity between tax on goods and tax on services.

The ones who stand to lose are the hapless consumers because the buck stops with them. Service providers may not begrudge this impost secure in the knowledge that at the end of the day their customers or, as the case may be, clients are going to pick up the tab. Ditto for the imposition of a 12 per cent excise duty on computers, which were hitherto not liable for excise duty.


The Finance Minister P. Chidambaram, while slapping this duty, seemed to give credit for the brainwave to computer manufacturers who, he said, volunteered to pay this duty in order to become eligible for Cenvat credit on the inputs used by them in manufacturing computers. But it remains to be seen whether the computer manufacturers would be as magnanimous with their customers as they were with the exchequer.

However, in the matter of exempt-exempt-tax (EET), the middle-class has emerged the winner despite orchestrated lobbying by a section of economists to usher in this regime as commended by the Kelkar committee. What they wanted was tax being imposed at the time of maturity on tax-oriented small savings such as the PPF . Mercifully, the FM has not obliged them, perhaps for fear of antagonising the Left.

Whatever the motive, the reprieve is entirely well merited as EET is ahead of its time in a country where tax evasion is widespread.

The Finance Minister should not waste his ammunition on spoiling the party for the honest middle class and instead should train his guns on the hard-to-tax category. Slashing of customs duty to 5 per cent on a slew of life saving drugs, including for the dreaded AIDS and cancer, is welcome.

Textiles & Garments

Textiles and garments are bound to become cheaper what with the excise duty on man-made textiles coming down to 8 per cent from 16 per cent. On the direct taxes front, while standard deduction for the salaried class has not staged a comeback as wistfully wished by them, there are no shocks either.

The abolition of the economic criteria scheme for compulsory filing of income-tax return pursuant to which one living in a house of a specified size, for example, was ordained to file returns no matter that he had no taxable income is bound to be of some relief.

Its abolition incidentally vindicates the contention of those in the know that it had more nuisance value than anything else.

(The writer is a Delhi-based chartered accountant.)

More Stories on : Taxation | Budget

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
Rice processing

The lure of equity despite stretched valuation — Bias in favour of investments in MFs, insurance
No cheer for telecom users, service providers — Now, service tax on Net telephony
Domestic airlines get tax exemption for 1 more year
A new lease
Budget goes pro-investment; new taxes kept to minimum — FBT modified; small cars to cost less on duty cut; tobacco taxed
Boost to investment activity — Govt totally committed to fiscal prudence and continued reforms: Chidambaram
Central Plan outlay put at Rs 2,54,041 cr — Energy, social services & transport corner major chunk
Pay for more services
Metals: Reflected lustre
Big bonanza for the small car
A touch more than a stitch in time
Wiring up the nation
A few goodies for rural impetus, lower costs
Ramp up in resources for welfare
Tea industry hails allocation
Fiscal improvement
Let us make our destiny
Sighs of relief and dropped jaws — The FM seems content more at not ruffling many feathers
A shopper's day out
Small cars, ice-creams, colas cheaper; not so umbrellas, glassware

Taxes not recovered crossed Rs 1,11,000 cr
25 projects under e-gov plan
Services sector provides Rs 23,000 cr
Refractories: Marginally positive
No major reaction
Gathering pace
Judicious tinkering
Equity fund redefined
No special drive: auto parts sector
`There's further scope for reducing raw material duties to Asean levels'

Duty rationalisation for man-made textiles — More allocation for textile schemes; Rs 189 cr for textile parks
Excise duty cut, a boon for small carmakers — `Small cars' are Maruti 800, Wagon R, Zen, Alto, Hyundai Santro, Indica diesel
MFs keen to tap global opportunity
IT industry divided over impact of excise duty — Desktop, notebooks may turn costlier
Some habits don't die that easily
AMFI to seek clarifications on foreign investments
Towards a cutting edge tax system
Redeeming `Aam Aadmi'
Boost for Bharat Nirman
Charting a high-growth path
Calls everywhere, but search for energy
Succour for the old
Pinches more than it soothes
Accent on digitisation — The income-tax offices will undergo business process re-engineering
How the tax breaks pan out
Price cuts galore on small cars
Excise duty: Minor twists
Registrars, share transfer agents under service tax ambit — `12% levy is bad news for AMCs'
Tepid changes to corporate tax
Budget recedes in importance
The knowledge society
Investment boom
Let down on CST
The wind is blowing, take cover!
Thin attendance, minimal interruptions — Top CEOs at industry chambers largely non-committal
Corporates neutral to Budget proposals — It was on expected lines, say honchos
Offers in manufacturing, services
Boost for soya
MAT rates altered
Captains tuned in
`Fiscal deficit to come down'
`Good Budget for industry'
Stable tax structure welcomed
It'll promote export growth
Focus on rural sector
It gets 8 marks out of 10
Petroleum industry unhappy
Boost for auto sector
Duty cuts for plastics, hydrocarbons
Zero customs duty on set-top boxes to benefit manufacturers
Customs duty hike — Vanaspati industry disappointed
Wiring up India with highway networks
On the expressway
Higher allotment for highways
No relief for oil cos on pricing, duty structure
Pharma sector sulks as Budget ignores wish-list
A no-show for the pharma sector
`Not much for pharma sector'
Bleak outlook for pharma sector
More coal blocks for power sector
Budget disappoints shipping industry
Shipping management services expensive
Marginal duty cut for alloys, metals — Proposal to cut duty on mineral products to 5 per cent
Sugar sector feels let down — `No measures on de-control'
15 new services under tax net — Scope expanded in banking, financial services
If only consumers had lobbyists
Hails nod for tea protection fund
Tea industry hails allocation
Wah! Budget
`A boost to replantation'
`Will help exports'
Policy overhaul for coal sector
`No relief for domestic liquor players'
A mild choker
Additional excise irks cigarette cos
Tobacco shrugs off excise hike
FMCG prices to stay put
No reason to blush
Your small car will now be less expensive
Toyota not to hasten small car launch
Positive spin to auto ancillary
A ray of hope
Will colas be cheaper?
Priority in lending to food sector — Rs 1,000-cr corpus for refinancing loans
Priority sector status hailed
`Greater credit flow likely'
Of pasta, idli and dosa
`Expert panel to help gems sector'
`Viability gap funding' for semiconductor projects — New policy on cards to make India hub
`8% excise on packaged software not good'
`Hike in service tax a dampener'
A good fit for consumer
5 pc hike likely in landed cost
A fine cut for paper
Paper sector happy with excise cut
`Impetus for growth'
Constraint on raw material sourcing
Excise duty cut for paper products
`Likely to see flight of IP to tax-friendly nations'
Ice-creams cheaper? Maybe not all
Jute industry upset
Govt may dilute stake in non-navratnas
Going the extra mile for the farmer
Service tax, no hiccups for Concor
Service tax hike not to have inflationary impact
Bank deposits to get 80C deduction — Recapitalisation bonds to be converted into tradable securities
No bad news on income taxes
Tweaking the FBT
Fringe Benefit Tax provisions modified — India Inc not mollified, wants it to go completely
Outlay for tourism hiked
Quick Look

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2006, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line