Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Tuesday, Feb 28, 2006


Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Economic Survey

`Follow China model on labour market'
Revisit costs incurred on anti-poverty schemes

G. Srinivasan

It's time to focus on the quality of outcome of the various social sector programmes rather than their quantity or coverage.

New Delhi , Feb. 27

The pre-Budget Economic Survey (2005-06), presented to Parliament today by the Finance Minister, Mr P. Chidambaram, has been refreshingly bold in areas that are otherwise sensitive to the coalition government, even as it makes the usual adulatory references to the reforms accomplished and the results delivered in terms of robust numbers.

First, on the issue of food subsidy, dear to all political parties, the Survey rightly diagnosed that the extant food subsidy as a fiscal policy tool seeks to serve two separate and potentially conflicting objectives of protecting producers' interest through payment of `remunerative' prices and also keeping prices stable/low for consumers!

Welfare programmes

The Survey cites a recent performance evaluation of the public distribution system by the Plan panel.

The Programme Evaluation Organisation of the Planning Commission has estimated that to transfer one rupee to the poor, the Government spends Rs 3.65 in the form of food subsidy, indicating that cash or near cash transfer could lead to a big gain for the poor.

In a similar pragmatic vein, the Survey points out that the time has now come to shift emphasis and focus attention on the quality of outcome of the various social sector programmes rather than their quantity or coverage!

The labour paradox

Yet another bold statement in the Survey relates to labour laws and labour markets where it highlights the paradox of how the organised sector has accorded too much of job security for too long, while the unorganised sector too little to too many!

Citing various studies to corroborate how Indian labour laws are highly protective, making the labour markets relatively inflexible, it said consequently these laws have restricted labour mobility, which led to capital-intensive methods in the organised sector to the detriment of long-run demand for labour.

China model

To hammer home the point to the Left party allies supporting the Government from outside, the Survey avers that China, with a history of extreme employment security, has drastically reformed its labour relations and created a new labour market in which workers are highly mobile.

What is remarkable is that despite mass lay-offs and open unemployment, high rates of industrial growth particularly in the coastal regions of China helped their redeployment. Perhaps Indian authorities could take a leaf out of China's book.

Employment scheme

In the wake of the launch of the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) in the country, the Survey argues that if efficiently implemented this will decisively address the unemployment situation in the rural areas. It cautions about the choice of projects under the scheme so as to ensure that need-based and good quality assets and infrastructure are created in the rural areas.

With the NREGS being billed as a safety net, the Survey notes that the entire gamut of expenditure based on anti-poverty initiatives needs to be "revisited". As political parties use anti-poverty programmes as porks, how far this suggestion would be implemented is a moot point.

Need more reforms

Even as the euphoria over GDP growth rates exceeding 8 per cent in the last three years ending 2005-06 is mentioned in the Survey, it did not desist from stating policies and institutions need to be geared up to meet the specific requirements of the infrastructure sectors in the country, particularly a well-defined regulatory architecture to increase the comfort level of the different players in the market.

The reform of the tax regime still remains an unfinished task the Survey said, adding that, "Indian industry needs to be unburdened from the high levels of taxes and the distortive exemptions that provide perverse incentives".

One can only hope that the Budget makes some sensible moves to set right this perversity.

The Survey's exhortation over inflation and hardening of interest rates in the light of unrelenting spurt in global crude prices and unresolved global macro-economic imbalances needs to be heeded.

Its well-laid prescription for ensuring better productivity in expenditure and getting greater growth dividend through deepening the reform process is to be followed for harnessing higher savings and investment to cruise on a sustainable non-inflationary higher growth path over the medium-term.

More Stories on : Economic Survey | Labour Reforms

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
Economic Survey proposes reforms in tax system
Pegs growth rate at 8.1 per cent; cites crude prices as a risk factor

Interest rates may firm up: Survey
`Forex reserves accretion slowing, credit offtake keeps rising'

`Rapid, bold policy responses needed to manage oil crisis'
Petro-product pricing crucial to fiscal health

`Follow China model on labour market'
Revisit costs incurred on anti-poverty schemes

Delhi, Mumbai airports revamp to begin mid-year
`In-principle' decision on Chennai airport revamp taken

Textile sector registers `moderate' export growth
Lags behind China in tapping free quota regime

Govt told to clarify rationale for postal subsidy
`Auto exports stay untapped'
Need for reforming labour laws stressed
Learn lessons from the Chinese model, says Survey

Govt sure of reining in inflation at 5 pc
Urban infrastructure: Call for user-charge approach
Smaller cities find the going tough due to financial crunch

Broadband is the next frontier
All States told to implement VAT
Contracts for stretches under NHDP to be awarded soon
India Inc says it's pragmatic
How critical is rural employment?
To bridge urban-rural divide

Automotive testing unit in Assam launched — Facilities to be used for N-E
JK Cement fixes IPO price at Rs 148
Food subsidy growth seen at 1.55 pc
Fertiliser subsidy to exceed Budget estimates
Total subsidy may cross Rs 24,000 crore

`Growth outlook bright'
Core sector growth slows to 3.3% in Jan
India Inc positive on growth: Survey
EU move to boost carbon trading — All flights must buy credits to offset GHC emissions
Indo-Arab meet begins — IT, medical tourism, bio-tech thrust areas
Three more Bio-safety Level 3 labs
Will Budget bring relief to cancer, AIDS patients?
Reconsider airport update plans: Panel
KCCI to identify developers for multi-product component in SEZ
Panel to decide on gas transmission tariff of GAIL
Gas supply issue: Meet today to resolve deadlock
Chiefs of Panna-Mukta venture partners, GAIL to participate

High credit rating for ONGC bonds
CDC supplies diagnostic reagents for bird flu investigation
Pharma industry clocks healthy growth
Leverage strengths in organic synthesis, process engineering

NPPA recovers Rs 99 cr from drug cos
Concern over power sector
`Electricity to all houses'
Sponge iron issues
Misplaced optimism?
Sugar output figures

Will Budget dilute FBT provisions, usher in EET?
Lower level of peak customs duty, rationalisation of duties for petroleum industry likely

Cotton growers worried over likely duty cut
Textile industry seeks special rules of origin provisions
NTPC plans joint venture with Coal India
AC to beat bird flu?
Food processing: Govt bid to woo big biz houses
Foundation stone laid for three RPG group projects
Goenkas tie-up with Godrej Group for shopping arcade

IT cos seek tax reliefs
MAIT wants excise anamolies removed

Coimbatore textile fair to feature `China Pavilion'
Over 300 companies covering all segments will be participating

Biotech industry seeks extension of deductions
A touch of glass
Exim Bank to invest $7 m in animated feature film
Rich Crest-Lions Gate's production

Women managers' meet on March 8
Theme inspired by Kalam's vision

`Core sector can absorb $150 b FDI'
ICRISAT partners CII in rural growth plan
TRAI says `end differential tariff'
Goan assessees for changes in I-T Act
I-T Dept to step up vigil against tax offenders

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2006, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line