Financial Daily from THE HINDU group of publications
Friday, Jan 14, 2005

Port Info

Group Sites

Industry & Economy - Economy

Raghuram Rajan for calibrated roll-out of economic policies

Our Bureau

Dr Raghuram G. Rajan (right), Chief Economist, IMF, and Mr Arvind Datar, Trustee, Palkhivala Foundation, at a lecture in Chennai on Thursday. — Bijoy Ghosh

Chennai , Jan. 13

INDIA is a large and complex country and as such, it would be unwise to roll-out major economic policies nation-wide in one go. Instead, it would be better if policy initiatives are implemented first over a smaller area on experiment basis and taken nation-wide, if successful, Dr Raghuram G. Rajan, Chief Economist, International Monetary Fund, USA, said on Thursday.

Or, economic policies could be implemented countrywide for specified, temporary periods of time before they are "set in stone", he said, delivering a speech on `Mindset to succeed in a globally competitive economy'. The lecture was organised by the Palkhivala Foundation.

Later, to a question on whether India should go carefully while liberalising its economy, Dr Rajan observed that the country's liberalisation was more in "fits and starts" than carefully thought through.

He pointed out that the process of liberalisation itself started in 1991 when India was in a crisis. If indeed liberalisation was carefully thought through, then India ought to be seeing a lot more of experimentation with various economic policies, as China does.

The questioner had spoken laudably of India having been immune to the South-East Asian crisis of 1997 because the country was fortunate not to have capital account convertibility (when the Indian rupee could be bought by or sold for any other currency by anybody).

Dr Rajan replied that the fact that India escaped crisis contagion did not necessarily mean that its policies were right.

The country not being affected was like "dead man feels no pain", he said.

He observed that in 1960, South Korea had the same per capita income as India did.

But today, the per capita income of South Korea was $8,000, compared with India's $500. In the last 40 years, South Korea had to face economic crisis, not just once in 1997, but three times.

India similarly needs to have capital account convertibility, Dr Rajan said.

He noted that although the country had liberalised its economy considerably, there was a long way to go. Indian economy was still closed in many ways, including absence of free capital account convertibility. He further noted that the country had initiated the most number of anti-dumping duties and had restrictions on foreign labour and investment.

Stressing that the country was not by nature xenophobic, Dr Rajan attributed India's slow opening up to what is called `lump of labour fallacy' on the part of the industry and lack of awareness of the benefits of opening up on the part of the people.

`Lump of labour fallacy' theory suggests that when more (foreign) companies get in, existing (India) companies' share of the pie shrinks.

This, Dr Rajan said, is not true, because the pie actually gets bigger and the existing companies prosper more.

He noted that Indian corporates were beginning to realise this.

But to change the mindset of people, he said that pro-growth policies would inevitably lead to short-term problems such as job losses, against which there should be a safety net.

It could be in the form of unemployment insurance, designed in such a way that it did not encourage the jobless to stay at home.

Dr Rajan was against inviting foreign investment by giving sops. He wanted a proper playing field for domestic investments.

Article E-Mail :: Comment :: Syndication :: Printer Friendly Page

Stories in this Section
Raghuram Rajan for calibrated roll-out of economic policies

`Reform-driven countries must formulate credible policies'
Bengal seeks fiscal incentives for 6 districts
Move for Nanotech Park, clusters for electronic units
Indo-UK trade panel launched
Look at this!
Meet on facial defects in Hyderabad
Cabinet refers SEZ Bill to GoM
Kerala observe oil conservation fortnight
Health, food supplement cos eye Indian market
Move afoot for Rs 3,000-cr HVDS power project
FAITMA signs MoU with Germany
Govt plans merger of two textile schemes
Ceiling on capital subsidy for powerloom sector hiked
Nov bus, truck tyre output dips
Sibal for investment in HR resources
Harvard varsity plans office in Mumbai
Stanford B-school plans programmes for growing cos
ISB to consider high CAT scores
`Auto component units must invest more in R&D'
Dazzling pebbles
Chamber hails Press Note 18 changes
`Plea to set up passport office in Mangalore'
AP Govt staff urged to wear handloom
Redemption of 10.5 pc special securities to hit NSSF income
Canara Bank signs pact with Ministry for rural schemes
`Entertainment industry yet to gear up for digital era'
PM's Relief Fund: Clarification on 80-G benefits
Tsunami: Japan offers assistance in reconstruction
Bhuj experience proves useful in Andamans
IMA disaster management cells
Pictures of missing persons
Singareni donates to CM fund
Contributions to The Hindu Relief Fund

The Hindu Group: Home | About Us | Copyright | Archives | Contacts | Subscription
Group Sites: The Hindu | Business Line | The Sportstar | Frontline | The Hindu eBooks | The Hindu Images | Home |

Copyright 2005, The Hindu Business Line. Republication or redissemination of the contents of this screen are expressly prohibited without the written consent of The Hindu Business Line